Cables From The Diplomatic Frontlines - As Blinken engages in shuttle diplomacy we revisit the essential preconditions for a durable peace.
In spite of major obstacles, a two-state solution is achievable - Biden has sufficient levers to pull off a historic diplomatic breakthrough.
Things are once again moving fast in the Middle East.
After years of crystallizing status quo, conditions finally exist to enable a realistic diplomatic breakthrough between Israel and Palestine.
A number of stakeholders have incentives to resolve the Gaza and West Bank issue once and for all.
We have previously looked at the incentives behind the Saudi proposal for peace: recognition of Israel, and investing into reconstruction (together with the UAE) in exchange for a ‘‘pathway’’ to a Palestinian statehood.
First off, it is a good cover and an excuse to get back to the normalization process.
With Iran edging ever closer to acquiring a nuclear bomb (with its skies soon better protected with Russia’s Su-35s and S-400 air defense SAMs) Saudis are eager to snatch a closer defense pact with the US.
But for that to even be on the table (their ideal scenario of a full-on security guarantee is likely to be dismissed - but some commitment of specific weapons/supplies/guarantees from Washington may still prove to be a major win for Saudis) they will need to recognize Israel.
And how could they do that right now?
In the middle a humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza?
Ignoring the Palestinian plight would crush their credibility and aspirations for Arab leadership completely.
So they need an excuse to restart these talks.
And if they succeed in actually achieving their end-goal of forming a Palestinian state, then they will get to promote their diplomatic heft.
Saudis would claim credit for ending the Gaza war, and for their major role in forming a sovereign state of Palestine.
If they fail however, they can reframe it as an earnest effort, highlight Israel’s unreasonableness and intransigence, and remain in a position to seek their original security guarantees from the US by pointing out that they (Saudis) did ‘‘everything that they could”, but that Israel was the spoiler.
Win and claim massive credit.
Lose and reframe it as failure of all - of the entire international community failing to overcome Israeli intransigence.
So it is mostly all upside for Saudis.
That Saudis and the UAE have strong incentives to resolve the Palestine issue (and legitimize their normalization with Israel, while weakening Muslim Brotherhood offshoots like Hamas) is pretty clear.
Add to that, Egypt is also increasingly anxious to solve this problem once and for all.
For a start, creation of a Palestinian state would put a decisive end to a wild (far-right) Israeli ambition to deport Gazans into (Egypt-controlled) Sinai.
But the humanitarian crisis, possibility of Hamas fighters moving into Egypt (and forming another/new base for Muslim Brotherhood - challenging & destabilizing Al-Sisi’s regime) and significant reduction in revenue from fewer Suez canal crossings (due to Houthi attacks in the Red Sea) are all causing additional headaches for Cairo: and for a country already on the brink and in need of IMF bailouts, the desire to end this conflict (and do its own part in accomplishing this) is strong.
In other words, key stakeholders are on board - with the exception of Israel.
Public mood in Israel has changed drastically following October 7th attacks.
Whereas previously, the majority of Israelis (61%) supported the idea of a Palestinian state - this has now reversed: with 65% now opposing it.
In addition, Netanyahu has also repeatedly ruled out recognition of Palestine.
He will continue to argue that this would be unacceptable to Israel’s national security needs (the very opposite of truth), and will use this new opposition to ‘‘external/global pressure on Israel’’ to attain new grounds for legitimacy - hoping to extend his rule further.
But with that said, the levers to sway all stakeholders - including Israel - are available to the Biden admin.
To be clear, there are formidable obstacles to surmount, and an utmost level of diplomatic finesse will be needed to attain this outcome.
But the levers are there, and in combination with certain fortuitous changes on the ground, conditions to resolve this long-standing issue do exist.
So what needs to happen for a two-state solution to become a reality?
The following elements must be in place:
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Bismarck Cables to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.