Cables From The Diplomatic Frontlines - Israel vs Hezbollah and Iran escalation: Netanyahu's objectives and calculations.
Israeli response to Hezbollah and how far can Netanyahu go.
Following Saturday's rocket strike, Israeli military response was inevitable.
Israel has now killed a senior Hezbollah commander in a suburb of Beirut (a long way away from Hezbollah strongholds in the south - a clear signal that Israel is willing to expand the war beyond the usual remits.) and the leader of Hamas’s political wing, Ismayil Haniyeh.
Both assassinations are a significant escalation - but clearly, the killing of Haniyeh was a far more monumental event.
First off, this was yet another demonstration and warning: that Israel possesses an incredible reach and can carry out assassination of high value targets right in Iranian capital with precision strikes.
Also, the assassination of Haniyeh took place shortly after he attended the inauguration of the new President.
The timing of his assassination is an additional show of disrespect to the Iranian regime.
All of this means that Iran will now have to respond somehow.
(side note: there is also of course a serious impact on Israel - Hamas negotiations. On the one hand, Israel just killed their main diplomatic interlocutor in Hamas. One can therefore assume that for Netanyahu, this was a neat way out of negotiations: kill two birds with one stone. On the other hand however, if the military wing leader Yahya Sinwar is killed too, then Netanyahu (or another Israeli PM) can claim a total victory and this would let Israel agree to a ceasefire without letting any serious Hamas leader “getting away” with it.)
It will be tough to calibrate a response that is hard enough to appear sufficient and yet weak enough to not create a pretext for further significant Israeli strikes and a potential full-on war.
At this point it is also worth mentioning that for Iran, the threat to its regime can come from many directions.
We usually focus on the bottom-up grassroots pressure, but the opposite can also happen.
For months now, Iran has been absorbing Israeli slights and accepting symbolically valuable losses without a strong show of force.
And although April's missile barrage appeared grandiose, it did little in the way of actual harm to Israel.
The fact of the matter is that Iran was unable to exact a proportionate response: while its senior commanders were killed in an Israeli missile strike in Syria, its own response did little in the way of actual damage.
Not only were there no corresponding casualties in Israeli command, there was little actual damage overall.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Bismarck Cables to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.